The Second Great Lesson | Part 1: The Coming of Life
In my training, there is a lesson between The First Great Lesson and the presentation of The Timeline of Life, called the Coming of Life. It’s is a highly anthropomorphized story, very similar to the one Micheal Dorer has in this book. That’s really not my style, so I’ve always shied away from the lesson.
I’ve decided to rewrite it. This is my own version, unofficial in every way :)
You can include the experiments while you tell the story (like in the first great lesson) or you can have them available as follow-up work later. You get to make the rules here.
Preamble
[Recap 1GL]: Do you remember our First Great Lesson? We learned how the universe began with a big bang of energy. We watched as particles cooled and formed atoms, and atoms gathered to create stars and planets. We saw how our Earth formed with its mountains, oceans, and air.
At the end of our first lesson, we saw that Earth had rocks, water, and air: solids, liquids, and gases. The mountains stood tall, the oceans rose and fell, and the winds blew across the land. But our Earth was quiet and empty. There was no life yet.
Today, I want to tell you how this empty Earth became the perfect place for life to begin. This is the story of how the very first living things came to be on our planet.
The Goldilocks Zone
Life began on Earth because Earth was in the right place in our solar system. Here, and only here, is water watery. And all living things need water. Every living thing is juicy. Prick your finger, bite a peach: there’s juice in everything. You yourself are 70% water. There’s not a dry spot on the human body; water brings to every bit of every body everything it needs to live.
It’s strange to think how easily the chance for life to start might have been missed.
[Solar System Chart 2A]


Water stays liquid between 32 degrees (where it freezes into ice) and 212 degrees (where it boils into steam). That’s only a 180-degree difference.
Earth is not too close to the Sun and not too far away. On Mars, further from the sun a nice summer day is about -10 F, water is always solid ice. On Venus, a planet closer to the Sun, a regular day 900F, and water is always steam in the clouds. Just a small change in distance from the Sun is the difference between life and no life.
Earth is just the right size. If it were big, like Jupiter, it wouldn’t be a rocky planet. You can’t stand on Jupiter; it has no solid ground, it’s just a huge ball of gas. Jupiter is so big that 1,300 Earths could fit inside it. You can fit 1 million Earths inside the Sun, but you can only fit 1 thousand Jupiters inside the Sun. Big planets have a lot of gravity, and so can hold onto a lot of gas; small planets can only hold onto a little bit of gas.
Earth is small, but it isn’t too small. If it were as small as the moon, its gravity couldn’t hold onto a single cloud. There would be no wind, because there would be no air. Without air to trap heat, ice wouldn’t melt into water. Without water, we couldn’t have oceans, seas, lakes, rivers, ponds, puddles, rain, or juicy life.
And our sun- our star- also happens to be just the right size for life. Bigger stars have so much gravity that when they are born, they pull in all the dust and gas around them, leaving nothing to make planets. Then they burn hot and fast, they explode into a supernova! Little stars are cold and dim, like a pale night light. They don’t have enough energy to warm up planets. Life needs a warm and steady sun.
[Relative Proportions Chart 1A]


Our earth is just the right place for life to begin.
The Early Earth
The world as it was when life began would have killed you. The air was full poisonous gases: a mixture of ammonia and hydrogen sulfide (what you smell when you let an egg rot or smell household cleaners) and deadly methane gas, which has no smell but you can see as a flame on a gas stove. There was plenty of water, but there was no oxygen in the air.
[First great lesson chart 5A]


Without oxygen, you couldn’t take a single breath. Without the ozone layer that oxygen makes, the sun’s harmful rays would give you the worst sunburn ever. Even if you somehow survived the burning sun rays and the lack of air, you’d still die from the extreme heat or from volcanoes spewing lava everywhere.
The high spots were bare rock, perfectly clean, and the low spots were a sludgy, muddy, sticky mess of clay. This clay had simple carbon molecules that would have smelled a bit like rotting fruit and stinky cheese.
Primordial Soup
Four billion years ago, the early oceans of Earth were very different from our oceans today. They were filled with chemicals washed down from the rocks by rain. The water bubbled with gases from volcanoes. Lightning from constant storms struck the waters again and again, providing energy.
Scientists call this the “primordial soup” – a rich mixture of chemicals where the first steps toward life could happen. In this soup, simple molecules could join together to form more complex ones.
Building Blocks of Life
The primordial soup was full of simple carbon molecules. Carbon is special because it can connect to many other atoms, like a building block with connections on all sides.
Over millions of years, with energy from lightning, heat, and the sun, these carbon molecules connected in longer and longer chains. They formed amino acids, which make proteins, and nucleotides, which make DNA. These are the basic building materials that all living things need.
Experiment: The First Boundaries
[Drop oil into water]
Look how the oil forms drops in the water. It doesn’t mix in; it stays separate. The first living things needed boundaries too—something to keep their special chemicals inside and separate from the world outside.
[Gently stir to show how the oil droplets maintain their boundaries]
In the primordial soup, some molecules formed thin skins. Inside these tiny droplets, chemicals could be protected from the harsh world outside. This was one of the first steps toward life.
The First Living Cells
Sometime 4 billion years ago, something amazing happened in that primordial soup. Some blobs became alive.
What makes something alive? Living things can do three special things:
- They can take in energy from their environment
- They can heal themselves and grow
- They can make copies of themselves
The first living cells were probably simple bubbles with a thin skin. Inside were special molecules that could make copies using materials from outside the bubble. They weren’t plants or animals – they were much simpler than that. They were more like today’s bacteria, but even simpler.
Early Life’s Diet
The first living things needed energy to grow and make more of themselves.
When we need energy, what do we do? We eat food! But that’s not all, we also breathe in oxygen. Oxygen helps our bodies break apart the sugars in food completely so that we can get the most amount of energy out of it. Every breath you take helps all the cells in your body use the energy you got from food.
But Earth’s early atmosphere was poisonous! There wasn’t any oxygen yet! So the earliest living things didn’t have the key to unlock all the energy from their food. They got their energy a different way.
These early blobs used a process called fermentation. Without oxygen, they could only break sugar molecules partway. It’s like using just a small part of a battery’s power and leaving the rest unused.
For billions of years, this was the only way life could get energy. It was enough for tiny, simple cells, but not enough for bigger, more complex creatures.
The Best Invention Ever: Making Food from Sunlight
The biggest breakthrough was learning to make food from sunlight, this is a way to get energy without eating. It was invented by tiny blue-green bacteria (cyanobacteria). These bacteria are still around, they are what make puddles look green. They use energy from the sun to eat carbon dioxide gas.
Instead of eating sugar, they use sunlight to make their own sugar from water and carbon dioxide. When they finish making sugar, they have something left over: oxygen. These little bacteria began letting a lot of oxygen into the air…
[Botany Chart B: The Food Factory]


This should have killed everything! Oxygen was deadly poison to early bacteria. Before these blue-green bacteria, there was no oxygen in the air, so nothing had to worry about this poison. Unless oxygen is attached to other things—like hydrogen to make water or iron to make rust—oxygen by itself is a dangerous gas that burns bacteria up.
But blue-green bacteria evolved an ability to tie oxygen up with other molecules inside them. They were not only able to tolerate the poison but to use it. They learned to breathe.
Other bacteria got 2 units of energy from breaking sugars apart; cyanobacteria got 38 units of energy from breathing.
Earth’s Changing Atmosphere
Cyanobacteria changed the world. The oxygen they released accumulated in the atmosphere and is the oxygen you breathe today. Many of the earliest fermenting bacteria were poisoned by oxygen and became extinct. Others survived by staying in the deepest parts of the ocean where the oxygen couldn’t reach them. Some of their great-great-great grandchildren still live in those deep places today.
As oxygen built up in the atmosphere, new species of bacteria arose that could survive larger doses of the poison and use it for longer and longer procedures for manufacturing all sorts of complicated molecules that could not have come together by themselves in the primordial soup.
This oxygen also changed planet Earth itself. Much of the iron in Earth’s early oceans and rocks rusted when it touched oxygen. That’s why we find bands of rusty red iron in very old rocks – they show us when oxygen first appeared in our air.
By about 1.5 billion years ago, there was half as much oxygen in the air as we have today. A layer of special oxygen called ozone began to form high above the earth. This layer blocks the sun’s harmful rays that can give you a sunburn. The new oxygen-rich air made it possible for a new kind of cell to develop (eukaryote) – the kind that makes up all plants and animals on Earth today, including you and me! It uses oxygen, and plenty of it!
Conclusion
And so, from a barren Earth with rocks, water, and poisonous air, the first tiny sparks of life emerged. These simple cells, too small to even see, would change our planet forever. They would eventually give rise to all the amazing life we see today – the plants, the animals, and even us.
The story of life was just beginning. Those first simple cells would change in remarkable ways over billions of years. They would learn new tricks, gain new skills, and turn into countless different kinds of living things.
But that is a story for our next Great Lesson. For now, remember how remarkable it is that life began at all – on our just-right planet, in the just-right place, with the just-right conditions for those first tiny living things to appear.
Follow-Up Ideas and Extensions
- Make yogurt from milk
- Make bread with yeast
- Make and observe a compost heap, especially notice it’s heat
- Make rusty nails in a jar of water






